Skip to content

Motordom Defined

May 5, 2010

I use the term ‘Motordom‘ a lot in my posts.  So here’s an explanation.  (One thing for sure: it’s not about motors.)

Check out this photo of Vancouver from about 1905 – a world in which people moved about on feet, bicycle, horse, and, since 1887, in electric streetcars.   And all shared the same space.

(Here’s a moving image from the front of a streetcar in 1907 in Vancouver.  Or this one in San Francisco):

Actually, a photo of any city street in North America prior to 1915 reveals a kind of slow-motion anarchy. There were no centrelines, pavement markings, traffic signals or even stop signs.  Here’s one from Washington, D.C. 

 

Pedestrians crossed streets where they wanted, when they wanted. Business took place in the street. Children even played in the streets.

Into this mix came the automobile: a new form of transportation incompatible with old uses. As Peter Norton argues in his book “Fighting Traffic,” the automobile arrived as an intruder, and brought with it blood, grief and anger. 

So great was the carnage that mothers would place small memorials in the street where their children died.   Downtown businesses were concerned about congestion, as were engineers who thought it unfair when streetcars crammed with passengers were impeded by vehicles with only a single driver.

An alliance of automotive interests united to counteract the constraints on automobiles proposed by city councils, engineers, street railways and safety reformers. Made up of automobile clubs, dealerships and manufacturers, they were known as Motordom: a non-pejorative term for advocates of the Motor Age. And their singular accomplishment, as Norton describes it, was a revolutionary change in the perception of the street.  Motordom successfully redefined the roadway as a place primarily for cars.

Now the pedestrian became the interloper – the jaywalker. Those who wished to cross the street would have to go to an assigned place and walk between the lines – the crosswalk – or wait for a signal before proceeding. Children, for their safety, could no longer play in the street. 

Motordom was also successful at redefining the street as a free market, in which it was unfair to discriminate against a minority of users. The solution, as Motordom argued it, was not to favour one mode over another but to let consumer choice prevail.

Consequently, cities were redesigned to accommodate the automobile. Engineering’s task was to provide enough space for the car in order to avoid the congestion created by the car. In Los Angeles, for instance, the Major Traffic Street Plan of 1924 led to the widening of arterial roads in a crosstown grid. Little attention or money was paid to the transit system.

Vancouver in 1928 undertook a similar treatment authored by planner Harland Bartholomew (who had helped with the Los Angeles plan) and which  became the basis for street improvements through to the 1980s.

The success achieved by the expenditure of many millions on public works was short-lived: increasing the traffic capacity of major roads eventually made the existing problem worse. Wider streets initially eased congestion but they also encouraged more residents to leave public transportation for their automobiles, leading to more congestion.

The Depression and the War, however, took the pressure off. Meanwhile, engineers consolidated what they learned into their transportation handbooks, beginning in 1942. Newly emerging post-war municipalities incorporated these road standards and the accompanying parking requirements into their bylaws. Urban regions would be designed not just to accommodate the car and truck but to be designed for and ultimately dependent on them. All other transportation choices – transit, bicycle, foot – were secondary if not impractical.

 In 1956, Americans undertook the single biggest engineering project in history – the Interstate freeway system. The system – over 40,000 miles criss-crossing a continent – was largely built out in two decades. Towns and cities hardly knew what hit them.

At the time, mostly good things seemed to happen. Suburbia was the fulfillment of an American (and Canadian) Dream built on insured mortgages, technically magnificent infrastructure for water and roads, cheap land and even cheaper energy. The lifestyle made possible was broadly shared, optimistic, ebullient.

The combination of low densities and widely separated land uses along with the high-speed infrastructure of arterials and freeways, with abundant free parking for every use, meant that Motordom had succeeded beyond its expectations: the urban region was designed not just to accommodate the car but to be designed solely for the car – and the truck and the bus. So pervasive would vehicle-dependent design become that people rarely saw any alternative. Our lives were so organized around car-based mobility that no other option was seen as realistic.

Today, this is the same intersection as above in Washington, DC:

Motordom is now the world of auto-dependent urban planning.  And we, like fish in water, live in the world of Motordom.

About these ads
85 Comments leave one →
  1. Richard permalink
    May 5, 2010 5:28 pm

    Granville Street downtown is like those streets years ago. Hopefully, the city will end up keeping it that way.

  2. Rod Smelser permalink
    May 7, 2010 2:20 pm

    I have a question concerning the streets in Vancouver highlighted in your 1928 Harland Bartholomew map. Isn’t this the same grid of streets that UBC Prof Patrick Condon celebrates as the bones of the streetcar city?

Trackbacks

  1. re:place Magazine
  2. Freeway Buzz « Price Tags
  3. From Elsewhere – Urban Commentary
  4. Annals of Motordom – 1 « Price Tags
  5. Annals of Motordom – 2 « Price Tags
  6. Annals of Motordom – 3 « Price Tags
  7. Annals of Motordom – 4 « Price Tags
  8. Annals of Motordom – 5 « Price Tags
  9. Annals of Motordom – 6 « Price Tags
  10. Annals of Motordom – 7 « Price Tags
  11. Annals of Motordom – 8 « Price Tags
  12. Annals of Motordom – 9 « Price Tags
  13. Annals of Motordom – 10 « Price Tags
  14. Annals of Motordom – 11 « Price Tags
  15. Annals of Motordom – 12 « Price Tags
  16. Annals of Motordom – 13 « Price Tags
  17. Annals of Motordom – 14 « Price Tags
  18. Annals of Motordom – 15 « Price Tags
  19. Annals of Motordom – 16 « Price Tags
  20. Annals of Motordom – 17 « Price Tags
  21. Annals of Motordom – 18 « Price Tags
  22. Annals of Motordom – 19 « Price Tags
  23. Annals of Motordom – 20 « Price Tags
  24. Annals of Motordom – 21 « Price Tags
  25. Annals of Motordom – 22 « Price Tags
  26. Annals of Motordom – 24 « Price Tags
  27. Annals of Motordom – 25 « Price Tags
  28. Annals of Motordom – 26 « Price Tags
  29. Annals of Motordom – 27 « Price Tags
  30. Annals of Motordom – 28 « Price Tags
  31. Annals of Motordom – 29 « Price Tags
  32. Annals of Motordom – 30 « Price Tags
  33. Annals of Motordom – 31 « Price Tags
  34. Annals of Motordom – 32 « Price Tags
  35. Annals of Motordom – 33 « Price Tags
  36. Annals of Motordom – 33 « Price Tags
  37. Annals of Motordom – 34 « Price Tags
  38. Annals of Motordom – 36 « Price Tags
  39. Annals of Motordom – 37 « Price Tags
  40. Annals of Motordom – 38 « Price Tags
  41. Annals of Motordom – 39 « Price Tags
  42. Annals of Motordom – 40 « Price Tags
  43. Annals of Motordom – 41 « Price Tags
  44. Annals of Motordom – 42 « Price Tags
  45. Annals of Motordom – 43 « Price Tags
  46. Annals of Motordom – 44 « Price Tags
  47. Annals of Motordom – 45 « Price Tags
  48. Annals of Motordom – 46 « Price Tags
  49. Annals of Motordom – 47 « Price Tags
  50. Annals of Motordom – 48 « Price Tags
  51. 100 Deathless Days « Past Tense
  52. Annals of Motordom – 49 « Price Tags
  53. Annals of Motordom – 50 « Price Tags
  54. Annals of Motordom – 51 « Price Tags
  55. Annals of Motordom – 52 « Price Tags
  56. Annals of Motordom – 53 « Price Tags
  57. Annals of Motordom – 54 « Price Tags
  58. Annals of Motordom – 55 « Price Tags
  59. Annals of Motordom – 56 « Price Tags
  60. Annals of Motordom – 21 « Price Tags
  61. Annals of Motordom – 58 « Price Tags
  62. Annals of Motordom – 59 « Price Tags
  63. Annals of Motordom – 60 « Price Tags
  64. Annals of Motordom – 60 « Price Tags
  65. Annals of Motordom – 61 « Price Tags
  66. Annals of Motordom – 62: Youth driving less … Even in L.A. … New low in 16-24 driver’s licences | Price Tags
  67. Annals of Motordom – 63 | Price Tags
  68. Annals of Motordom – 64: Road diet in Florida, Shanghai car costs, synchronized signals | Price Tags
  69. Annals of Motordom – 64: NYC in ’39; Decline in VMT; Demographics | Price Tags
  70. Annals of Motordom – 64: Prediction, Competition, HOT lanes | Price Tags
  71. Annals of Motordom – 65: End of Car Culture | Price Tags
  72. Annals of Motordom – 66: Oregon voluntary ‘tax’ … streamlined egg … | Price Tags
  73. Point Grey Road: (1) Seaside Completion or (2) Maintaining Motordom | Price Tags
  74. Annals of Motordom – 106: Sun cartoon … Driving Uncool … Generation Neutral? | Price Tags
  75. Motordom: Always Promoting the Next Big Project ← MUNICIPAL MATTERS
  76. Annals of Motordom – 68: Texas turns to gravel … | Price Tags
  77. Annals of Motordom – 69: Signal timing …. Signal design … Driving alone in Seattle | Price Tags
  78. Annals of Motordom – 68: Distractions … Mythology ’56 … Smart highways | Price Tags
  79. Annals of Motordom – 68: Another kind of toll … Black-box pricing … NACTO guide | Price Tags
  80. Annals of Motordom – 71: Tolling the Present … Predicting the Future … Measuring the Moment | Price Tags
  81. Annals of Motordom – 71 | Price Tags
  82. Annals of Motordom – 71: Honking … Blocking … Comparing | Price Tags
  83. Annals of Motordom – 71: Reducing traffic … | Price Tags

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 4,742 other followers

%d bloggers like this: